Greatest Physicist of All Time
14
Ṁ1292
3000
84%
Newton
80%
Einstein
44%
Maxwell
41%
Planck
41%
Fermi
41%
Heisenberg
41%
Dirac
40%
Archimedes
39%
Schrödinger
36%
Bose
34%
Lorentz
34%
Boltzmann
32%
Pauli
31%
Someone with high achievement in experimental physics
30%
Someone to cause a paradigm shift in understanding the physics of experience
27%
Someone who solves quantum gravity
25%
Bohr
25%
Poincaré
25%
Richard P. Feynman
22%
Ernst Mach

Anyone can add options.

Resolves when there is widespread consensus that quantum gravity is solved, or when quantum mechanics is proven wrong. Until then, a healthy discussion of the resolution criterion is appreciated.

By trading in this market, you agree to let me be the judge for subjective matters associated with this market (e.g., what counts as "widespread consensus"). When in doubt, ask before trading.

See also

https://manifold.markets/PuckMinder/greatest-inventor-of-alltime

https://manifold.markets/Bayesian/greatest-ai-researcher-of-all-time-nQyP98QSO6

https://manifold.markets/sixtynine/greatest-mathematician-of-all-time
https://manifold.markets/ttoe/greatest-philosopher-of-all-time

https://manifold.markets/ttoe/greatest-philosophical-work-of-all

https://manifold.markets/ttoe/greatest-physics-work-of-all-time

https://manifold.markets/ttoe/greatest-biologist-of-all-time

Resolution criteria proposed by traders so far:

1. Resolves according to a poll at market close. Top 10 options will resolve to 100%, 90%, 80% ... 10%. Other options resolve to No.

  • Update 2025-07-22 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): In response to a question, the creator has clarified that this market will not necessarily resolve to a single winner.

It may resolve to percentages based on a ranking of multiple physicists, similar to how the linked "Greatest Inventor of All Time" market was resolved.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:
reposted

It is left as an exercise for the reader to decide whether the fact Schrödinger was also a confirmed pedophile affects his greatness as a physicist, or if only his scientific accomplishments should be considered

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erwin_Schr%C3%B6dinger#Sexual_abuse_allegations

bought Ṁ3 YES

IMO Alhazen is entirely on the same level as Newton

Demokritos is known as Democritus in english, and likewise Ibn al-Haytham is sometimes known as Alhazen

Only one can resolve YES, right? The title says physicist, singular

@TheAllMemeingEye Not necessarily. This one resolves to percentages according to ranking even though the title uses singular word: https://manifold.markets/PuckMinder/greatest-inventor-of-alltime

Healthy discussions on how to resolve are welcome.

@ttoe I recommend adding this passage from that market to this one's description for clarity

Resolves to a poll at market close with all options. Top 10 will resolve accordingly.

  1. 100%

  2. 90%

  3. 80%

  4. 70%

  5. 60%

  6. 50%

  7. 40%

  8. 30%

  9. 20%

  10. 10%

Everyone else resolves No.

@TheAllMemeingEye Thank you fur the suggestion. I updated the description to include this as a candidate resolution criterion. Let's see if there are other suggestions, before I fix the criterion.

bought Ṁ10 YES

I don't think it's even close. Motion, gravity and optics? The man was the GOAT.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules