A player that already has a Super Bowl victory is not eligible. A back-up on a Superbowl winning team is not eligible UNLESS they make a significant contribution to the game. I will be a little conservative in closing out NO until a reasonable time has past or a player officially retires or explicitly says they will not be returning (Phillip River almost played in the SB 2 years ago!)

I reserve the right to make the final judgement, but will definitely hear arguments.

As more QBs enter the league (or make it up the ranks) I will add them!