Will Grok make a "really good movie" in 2027?
32
Ṁ3843
2027
14%
chance

Inspired by this:

https://manifold.markets/ScottAlexander/in-2028-will-an-ai-be-able-to-gener#afxuogp7anb

As per Musk's tweet, "really good" means a substantial increase over merely "watchable," but not to the level of high budget studio blockbuster. It must be a full length "movie," not merely a long video (e.g. video essay), or a short cohesive narrative/piece of art along the lines of a student film. And it must be made by Grok, although very modest human help is acceptable, so no need for 1-shot from the prompt.

This is obviously an inherently subjective market, but I will try my best to be fair and impartial. Now that the market is "initialized," I will not trade in it.

Fine print:

A movie
- Minimum length of 1 hour 15 minutes.
- Must be 1 cohesive narrative with continuous characters, plot elements, scene locations, etc.

Of "very good" quality
- Must be good enough for Musk to hype it as "very good" and not be clowned on by most of Twitter or the internet at large.
- Should be extremely impressive to neutral/mildly skeptical towards AI (as of 2025) Manifold users; anything more than rare, minor AI gen artifacts will invalidate.


Made by Grok

- The footage and sound must be 99+% generated by Grok (or other XAI video/audio generation AI); this is really just so that stuff like famous audio clips or similar content could be included such as the Wilhelm Scream.
- It can be made via multiple prompted video generations (minimum length 10m each, max 10 generations in movie) stitched together w/ light editing, but only if this doesn't break visual continuity of characters, scenes, etc. in a way that's obviously AI gen.
- It can't be meticulously micro-prompted & edited by a (team of) human(s) simply using Grok as a video/sound generator; this is to prevent weird scenarios where an insane amount of context is given to Grok cumulatively such that Grok is no longer doing most of the creative work.
- If video/audio can be fed into Grok's prompt(s), this must be less than 1% of the total movie length, except for if previous Grok video generations are fed into subsequent prompts (if this works, it's basically just a form of scaffolding).
- Similarly, lines of dialogue can't be primarily provided by the prompt(s): less than 10% of the movie dialogue can be word for word from the prompt(s).

I'm open to minor clarifications if anything is too vague or controversial, e.g. running a poll on if a submitted video is "very good", with the goal being a non-controversial resolution.

  • Update 2025-10-10 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): The market can resolve YES early if Grok makes a really good movie before 2027, since the creator reasons that if Grok can make a good movie before 2027, it can also do it (even better) in 2027.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:

I feel like it would be easier to track this through iMDB, Rotten Tomatoes, ... (critic) reviews

@Lilemont you might be right, although this explicitly doesn’t need to be as good as a “real”/high budget movie that critics typically review. And I also am mildly concerned about anti-ai bias from critics specifically.

Audience reviews make a lot of sense for this though, so I think that sounds like a good idea if it’s easy to implement/happens naturally. Although if AI becomes a large political issue then audience reviews could become even more negatively biased than critics, and if AI is advancing rapidly enough for this market to resolve yes, that’s substantially more likely.

What if the movie is made before 2027, but not in 2027?

@khang2009 it can resolve yes early, since if Grok can make a good movie before 2027, it can also do it (even better) in 2027.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules